An Inside Look At Squires' Discretionary Denials
Law360, Nikhil Krishnan & Todd Baker, September 3, 2026
Under U.S. Patent and Trademark Office Director John Squires, discretionary denial has become the single most significant obstacle to institution of America Invents Act proceedings. Since he took over institution decisions on Oct. 31, 2025, he has denied nearly 60% of petitions on discretionary grounds, without reaching the merits. Every discretionary denial decision issued by Squires between Oct. 31, 2025, and Aug. 25 this year, and corresponding briefs were analyzed. This article reveals the commonly asserted discretionary denial arguments and evaluates which arguments most strongly correlated with institution outcomes.